This movie is grossly underrated, but I think that's because people went into it expecting something entirely different from what they got. They went in expecting one of the following: Die Hard in space, Star Wars, or Independence Day.
The first group saw the movie as cluttered -- they were expecting a simple action thriller where the hero is one person, *maybe* with a sidekick, and plenty of villanous cannon-fodder. What they got was a conflict between multiple heroes with individual agendas who all basically wanted the same thing but kept getting in each others' way. The fast editing, wild visuals, and bizarre costuming just made it look sillier.
The second group saw it as small-minded -- they were expecting a well-thought-out SF epic where an ancient evil must be defeated by an ancient and nicely arcane good. What they got was a farce where the mystical rituals were nothing more than plot devices and ultimately the fate of the universe rested on a bunch of self-centered idiots. They were disappointed when nobody explored the ancient Mondoshewan race, when the hero only visited one other planet and then came straight back to Earth, when the "ancient evil" had only a corporate executive as its lackey.
The third group were expecting a repeat of the previous year's hugely successful "Independence Day." They were expecting a massive invasion from hideous creatures that would ultimately be repelled by an unlikely but very plucky patriotic hero (or group of heroes) who boldly went out and saved the world in its hour of need. With a bit of wisecracking thrown in for comic relief. What they got was a hero who had to be *pestered* into saving the world, a general disrespect for authority, incompetant villains, incompetant heroes, and a general impression that the entire human race is a laughingstock. Worth saving, but still a laughingstock.
What all these groups didn't realize going in was that this movie is French. And this is *exactly* what French farce is all about. It's comedy, it's silly, it's surreal, it's not meant to be taken too seriously, and it is a way to accept that life is priceless, although those who live life tend to be quite ridiculous. How do the French have a low crime rate *and* a complete disrespect for authority? This is how. They don't really disrespect authority.
And that's what this is about. The world is about to end. And it's *funny*. Really. Not in the sense of your typical American situational comedies, but rather in the sense of French farce. That is to say, it's not the situation that's funny -- the situation is the direst of all imaginable tragedies. What's funny is the fact that everybody acts like an idiot in the face of it, from the military trying to take over despite having just proven they have no idea what they're doing, to the permanently baffled priest, to the government posturing uselessly away. It's a good movie, but you've got to understand that it's also a very silly movie. Go into it with a light heart and you'll enjoy. Don't expect adrenalin or epics or patriotism. This is about the human condition, and how fundamentally ridiculous it is.
stfu I loved it.
ReplyDeleteI love this film.
ReplyDeleteOne of my favourite films of all time, OF ALL TIME.
ReplyDeleteI honestly don't think anyone under rates this movie. My family and I had a discussion about it yesterday, all agreed to love the movie. The action is great, and the comedy is hilarious! Who under rates this classic? (no one.)
ReplyDeleteI've never met someone who didn't like the fifth element. Hardly seems underrated.
ReplyDeleteMe! I thought it was poorly done and not particularly interesting. Had I not been with a group, I would've left about halfway through. Sorry. Not looking to get flamed. Just thought I'd let everyone know that there are some people around who didn't like this movie.
DeleteSo in your opinion what is a great movie in the same genre?
DeleteOff the top of my head, I really don't know. I don't have to compare with something else to know whether or not I enjoyed the movie.
DeleteThe Hitchhiker's guide!!!
DeleteAs much as I dug the book, I wasn't thrilled about the Hitchhiker's Guide movie.
DeleteBut, since you can't name a movie you liked in the same genre, maybe that just means you don't like this genre, and shouldn't have seen the movie to start with...
DeleteIts a sci-fi princess bride to the core.
DeleteI'm the one who originally said I didn't like the movie, responding to comment about maybe not liking the genre. I don't think that's the case, though what genre would you put this film in? Sci-Fi? I like several sci-fi movies quite a bit. Sci-Fi comedy? Well, I liked Mars Attacks for what it was... not incredible, but cheesy and enjoyable. French Sci-Fi Comedy? Don't know what else would be in that genre, but there are several French films I enjoy.
DeleteBut even if it isn't a genre I enjoy, the comments didn't seem to be about how people who like this specific genre love this film. Statements were simply about how most people didn't know anyone who didn't like it. And for whatever reason, even having seen it twice, I don't care for it. Didn't find it clever, funny or interesting. Will give it credit for interesting visual stylization.
Cheers.
I would postulate that the major reason why this movie is underrated is the fact, that it does picture the future of the human race as a consumerist slum.
ReplyDeleteThis is the major reason why I love the movie, but most people expect the StarTrek perfect human master race.
Star Trek was always about what we *could* be.
DeleteFifth Element is about what we will *probably* be. And it's still a future I'd want to live in. Also hilarious.
Excellent assessment. Clearly the accepted movie formula is someone or something attempts to destroy the wonderful world we live in, and it takes the good guy to come along, and accept the ultimate battle to save everything we've ever wanted in life.
DeleteIn the Fifth Element, Luc Besson shows this world we'd all despise from McDonalds, Ruby Rod, gun crazy & corrupt violent cops, government dominated by the Military/Industrial complex, and of course the mega corporation dominating the universe who'd stop at nothing to increase it's profit/wealth(even though it doesn't understand it means it's destruction). With the solution bonding together a burned out ex-military person, a priest who has no concept of the power he is responsible for, and the super being who only wants to feel affection and love.
While it may be difficult to call this science fiction, the film does have futuristic styling and aliens. Star Wars did the same. But Star Wars also had the Force which is not rooted in science fiction. The Fifth Element has love as the saving force in place of the Force. As once author critic stated, in Science Fiction, science is the agent of change.
ReplyDeleteSo it's difficult to pigeon hole this film as any one genre. Although we could call it comedy, fantasy, action, adventure, etc., the important issue is not to argue it one way or the other.
We just need to appreciate it for the awesome movie that it is. And yes, it's very funny!
Great article!
Science fiction means fictional science. The force and "The power of love" are fictional science aka science that doesn't exist. Science fiction.
Deleteyou're wrong, science fiction use unlikely or unreal SCIENCE, not magic. so yeah, star wars has scifi elements like spaceships and lightsabers but it also has fanstasy elements like the force (various magic bits melted together)
Deleteyou don't believe in love? i'm sorry.
DeleteThe power of love to be a dramatic influence in our lives, something to strive for and revel in? Absolutely!
DeleteThe power of love to physically affect anything other than your own emotional state? Ehhh, not so much.
Lucas tried to slather some science fiction on his magic with the midoclorians and it was a stupid stupid idea. Personally I'd have to go with the first anonymous reply here. Star Wars is set in a universe where the force exists as a real thing. That's just another kind of sci-fi, where 'hard'er science fiction is closer to our own universe. Warp drive in Star Trek is a lot more technical than the force, but it's otherwise not much different. The force or the power of love isn't enough to say that something isn't Sci-fi.
This movie is easily in my top 3.
ReplyDeleteIt's one of the most quotable movies I have ever seen and it's a damn shame that almost nobody gets when I reference it.
Definitely an underrated movie.
Lilu Dallas Multi-Pass!
ReplyDeleteI loved that movie, but not for your reasons. Therefore you're wrong and pretentious so go fuck yourself.
ReplyDeleteYou sir, are a fucking idiot.
DeleteAnd you are a faggot.
DeleteAnd I am better than all of you.
DeleteI think people appreciated the comedy more than they appreciated the ending. Love isn't an element, and it is a huge, cliche cop-out to make love save the world. It's like enjoying a great burrito, and then pooping your pants when you fart. No matter how good the burrito was while you were eating it, you'll just remember it for the poop at the end.
ReplyDeleteMila was smokin hot in this movie so much so that the rest of the movie could have been a total turd and it still would be worth watching. Good thing the rest wasn't a turd. Loved this movie.
ReplyDeleteThe only thing I didn't like about Fifth Element was the "I'm bad because I enjoy being bad" villain. Only Gary Oldman's superb acting skills kept that character from being a black hole in an otherwise fantastic movie.
ReplyDeleteDude, he doesn't care about anything but profit; in the context of the movie, too much does he care about profiting financially.
DeleteI loved the movie and I've noticed that many of my friends did not. The one thing they couldn't take was the Ruby Ross character. That one character was make or break for most of the people I've talked with. If they thought he was funny ridiculous, they liked the movie. I they though he was annoying ridiculous they didn't care for the movie.
ReplyDeleteUnderrated? Where did you get that from? Please explain how 7,5 on IMDB is "underrated"? Budget: $90 million - Box office: $263.9 million. None of my friends dislike this movie, NOT ONE! So by all means explain what the hell you mean by "underrated".
ReplyDeleteHe mean its worth 7,6
DeleteIt's underrated because he or she didn't like it the first time he watched for reasons 1-3, stated above, and then only liked it after watching it again after all his or her friends raved about it.
DeleteMy 12 year old daughter was watching it the other day and asking a volley of questions, she's really smart but she still out of curiosity tries to figure things out. I told her "Look,the first thing you need to realize is thia is a FRENCH film in every way.. The costumes,the attitude... don't try to completely understand it, just enjoy."
ReplyDeleteWhat an excellent review of an excellent movie.
ReplyDeleteWatch"Le Dernier Combat" for a veiw of whats to come from Luc Besson
ReplyDeleteI love this movie!!, makes me laugh out loud everytime I watch it!
ReplyDelete73% on Rotten Tomatoes.
ReplyDeleteNot sure who is underrating the movie.
My husband introduced me to this movie years ago, and I fell in love with it. Definitely an under-appreciated gem. One of our pet snakes is even named Leeloo.
ReplyDeleteI named my daughter after Leeloo (slight spelling difference) as she is the perfect being in my life.
ReplyDeleteI've run into hard-core haters of this movie and I never understand it, it seems so universally awesome to me. The haters do exist out there. Still remember a couple I hung out with in the late 90's who said they walked out of it in the theatre... I didn't really get to ask them details of why, because I got the hell away from them and didn't go back.
ReplyDelete12 monkeys was also very good
ReplyDeleteVery good analysis. I never understood it until I saw it one time on LSD, then it became clear & brilliant to me...
ReplyDeleteOne of my Favorite Films, sat proudly next to aliens on my Film rack
ReplyDeleteExcellent article. It has always amused me the the director of such testosterone-charged American flicks as Independence Day and 2012 is a gay German man.
ReplyDeleteI always loved it.
ReplyDeleteYou know who doesn't like The Fifth Element?
ReplyDeleteASSHOLES.... that's who.
This movie isn't underrated at all WTF everyone loves it
ReplyDeleteNext you're going to post about how Nikola Tesla is an unknown genius, yes?
All the things the movie wasn't are exactly why it's so great. It's got elements of all those things, which was an insanely brave production choice and makes this film kind of stand out in my mind as one of the more unique blockbusters ever made.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI viewed it as a futuristic Hudson Hawk, another grossly under-rated movie. Thought it was genius.
ReplyDeleteThe first thing you have to realize is that all French movies are bad.
ReplyDeleteThe first thing you have to realize is that all French movies are bad.
ReplyDeleteJust finished wat hing the movie. Great movie, i love it.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.doubleviking.com/real-men-love-the-fifth-element-6198-p.html
ReplyDeleteplenty of people underrate this movie, even though it's a masterpiece. everyone's casted greatly, and it's got so many elements to it. people do underrate it though, i'd say more people dislike this movie than those that like it, and if you say otherwise you obviously have more faith in American society than us realists. as for all french movies being bad, every luc besson movie is brilliant except for the transporter sequels. the district 13 movies are really bad ass if you doubt, far better than most American action movies. another good one is High Tension, one of the best horror movies I've ever seen.
ReplyDeleteOh no, this movie is brilliant. I've disposed of everyone who ever said otherwise.
ReplyDeleteWill Smith was hilarious in this movie.
ReplyDeleteyou are retarded
ReplyDeletethis is one of my favorite cyberpunk movies of all time!
ReplyDeleteI've always thought that the ending (the Universe is saved by the light that emits from a supermodel's chest) didn't live up to the rest of the movie.
ReplyDeleteWell, no one really cares about your opinion since you probably watched the movie one time way back in 1997 seeing as how you think that light came out of mila jovovich's chest. poser fail
ReplyDeleteGreat film!
ReplyDeleteI know not what you speak of. Fifth element is one of me Favorite Movies.
ReplyDeletewell, unless you're the anonymous poster from above with the dumb comment, it wasn't directed towards you. fifth element is brilliant, through and through
ReplyDeleteI've always loved The Fifth Element. It was much fun to see it in the theaters and still is.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed your article but I wish you had titled it "The French Element"
ReplyDeleteI LOVE THIS MOVIE!!
ReplyDeleteI never get tired of this movie! Gary Oldman rocks!
ReplyDeleteI must've watched this at least 10 times already :D
ReplyDeleteThis post helped me articulate why this is my favorite movie. thank you.
ReplyDeleteAmazing movie right there with star wars for me
ReplyDeleteI remember seeing this movie as a kid, loved it then and still do today. Idk how many times I've watched it.
ReplyDeleteGreat movie!